JUDGE NOT
Sirach 27:4-7; 1 Corinthians 15:54-58; Luke 6:39-45
A friar in a monastery committed a fault. The superior called the council to decide his punishment. The council assembled, but Friar Joseph, a senior monk, was not present. The superior sent someone to call him. When Friar Joseph came, he was carrying a leaking jug! When the others saw this, they asked him what it meant. The wise friar said: “My sins run out behind me, but I do not see them. And today I am coming to judge the error of another?”
The gospel is a continuation of the Sermon on the Plain and Jesus’ injunction to not judge. What Jesus forbids is not judgment per se, but negative/destructive judgment. Our judgments should be like those of Jesus: judging to save and help, not to knock down and destroy. We must not pass judgment without understanding the person and his/her situation, and without an awareness of our faults. Much of our criticism is, perhaps, a form of self-defence or a pre-emptive strike! To offset our feeling of insecurity, we pull others down.
“Judge not” is not a cover for immoral behaviour; not a prohibition on admonishing others; not an endorsement of moral relativism.
“Judge not” is an elaboration of the Golden Rule—we should treat others the way that we want to be treated. Given that God will judge us, what kind of judgment do we want? We want a judgment done with mercy, compassion, and forgiveness. That’s the way we ought to treat others: with mercy and compassion.
Do I see the worst or the best about others? When I judge others, am I aware of my faults and shortcomings? Am I merciful and compassionate?
After a pastor preached on spiritual gifts, a lady told him: “Pastor, I believe I have the talent of criticism.” He asked her: “Remember the person in Jesus’ parable who had the one talent? Do you recall what he did with it?” She replied: “Yes, he went out and buried it.” With a smile, the pastor suggested: “Go thou, and do likewise!”
May we bury our negative and destructive criticism and use our gifts of love and compassion.